While gutter guards offer many benefits, they also have potential downsides that homeowners should seriously consider before signing on the dotted line. Look out and be warned because lots of gutter guard companies employ smooth talking sales people who arrive at your house with a clipboard (and no ladder) promising you the world when it comes to gutter protection. Some of these companies even offer ludicrous 30 year guarantees that they know are impossible to vouch for in the long term.
Here’s a Breakdown of Potential Downsides
Maintenance is Still Required
Contrary to some claims, gutter guards don’t totally eliminate the need for gutter maintenance entirely. Most gutter guards still need cleaning. Debris can still accumulate on top of the guards, and smaller particles may find their way into the gutters. Once this happens, you’ll have a new problem; blocked gutter mesh. Cleaning out old gutter guards will be more challenging than cleaning open gutters, as you will need to remove or partially disassemble the guards.
Debris Accumulation
Small debris, such as pine needles, seeds, and fine particles, can still get through some types of gutter guards, particularly those with larger aperture holes. Once debris accumulates on top of the guards, water flow will be hindered and what do you know? “Maintenance is still required”…
Potential for Roof Damage
Where inexperienced contractors have been used, improper installation of gutter guards can damage roof tiles, metal sheets and shingles which will void roof warranties. The extra weight of heavier gutter guard systems, especially when combined with accumulated debris, or ice, can put stress on the fascia and roof structure. We have seen countless gutters falling away from the internal brackets due to too much stress on the gutters.
Cost
Gutter guards may be a significant upfront investment, especially for professionally-installed systems. The type of clipboard carrying sales guys we mentioned above will always want you to “sign up now and save.”
Hidden Debris and Blockages
Gutter guards can obscure visibility, making it difficult to detect debris buildup and blockages within the gutters. It’s only once weeds start growing through that you will know they’re blocked.
Winter Issues
In colder climates, ice can form on and within gutter guards, potentially leading to ice dams and increased weight on the gutter system with all the apertures actually blocked with ice. In Melbourne and Victoria this actually happens on extremely cold, frosty mornings.
Aesthetic Impact
Lots of gutter guard systems will alter the appearance of your home’s exterior. If heritage overlay is a concern, only get inserted gutter guards because the ones that screw on and cover the roof edge will probably not be allowed by your local council.
Moss and Algae Growth
If some debris gets into the gutters and holds moisture, it can cause moss and algae growth. This issue can be compounded if the gutter mesh obstructs sunlight from getting in, because initially this will create an environment for weed roots to flourish.
Key Considerations before Installing Gutter Guards
The effectiveness of gutter guards varies depending on the type of guard, the surrounding environment (e.g., the number and type of trees), and the quality of installation. Take note that with a proper roof plumbing system in place and regular tree pruning, most gutters require cleaning only about once yearly. That said, many property owners get away with clearing their gutters every 5-10 years.
Regular inspection and maintenance are crucial, even with gutter guards.
By understanding these potential downsides, homeowners can make informed decisions about whether gutter guards are the right solution for their needs! If you do insist on getting gutter guards we recommend the Triple-G system because it’s easier to remove if necessary.
For gutter cleaning and gutter guard servicing, call us now on 1300 BOX GUTTER (1300 269 488).